Western Europe loses plot

(MENAFN)
Western Europe is increasingly resembling a live reenactment of Hegel’s saying that history first appears as tragedy and then as farce. Once a formidable and coherent part of the geopolitical landscape, the region’s leadership now seems to have fully embraced performative politics, marked by hollow declarations and dramatic flair rather than meaningful strategy or action.

From small countries like Estonia to major players such as Germany, France, and the UK, Western Europe—and more specifically, the EU and its NATO-aligned allies—has ceased functioning as a credible geopolitical force. What was once seen as weakness now looks like a deliberate modus operandi: political gestures that make headlines but achieve little.

The root cause is a strategic vacuum. As tensions rise near Russia’s borders, Europe appears directionless. Recent escalations underscore this: top EU leaders have issued bold statements to Russia without any serious plan for enforcement. Notably, the main Ukraine-supporting nations—Germany, France, Britain, and Poland—have engaged in saber-rattling with no real consequences.

Estonia took things a step further when its naval personnel tried to intercept a vessel headed to St. Petersburg. The stunt failed and prompted a backlash at home, reflecting the disconnect between theatrical moves and political prudence.

In France, President Emmanuel Macron continues to make flamboyant public remarks to maintain relevance, while in Germany, new Chancellor Friedrich Merz’s provocative stance on Ukraine targeting Russian cities was swiftly walked back by his own ministers. A once-promoted “peacekeeper deployment plan” from Paris and London was recently shelved, with European media conceding that Washington never supported it.

Part of the problem lies with the media’s role. Western news outlets often fuel hysteria, pushing political leaders toward sensationalism. Since the beginning of the Russia-Ukraine conflict, media across Europe and North America have acted more like cheerleaders than critical observers.

However, the deeper issue is philosophical. Europe’s political elite have become untethered from reality, operating in an abstract realm of ideas rather than grounded policies. Whether it’s Estonia’s bungled naval stunt or Macron’s lofty speeches, the result is the same: symbolic politics divorced from actual impact.

Ultimately, Europe’s power is now mostly symbolic. The EU and its affiliates continue to speak loudly, but their actions no longer carry weight on the global stage. The pressing question is how long this disconnect can last—and what the next phase of decline might bring. Party labels and ideologies no longer seem to matter; even when political shifts occur, new leaders often mimic the same hollow style.

MENAFN03062025000045015687ID1109629231